Questions (so many) from an Amber fan group elsewhere, credit to Mandy Roosen:
So, I’ve been rereading the Merlin cycle, and… while interesting, the broken Patterns (BP) really are bringing up more questions and actually breaking the established canon. On the one hand, it makes sense. One could assume Rebma, Amber and Tir are “broken” Patterns from Primal Pattern. Yet, the rule is clear that that only Dworkin’s descendants can walk the patterns, while the BP’s can clearly be walked by anyone who dares, as Julia showed. So… what is it, now? Was the whole “Only Barimen blood can walk the pattern” a blatant lie to discourage people from walking it “en masse”?
Moire did send a lot of people upon Rebma’s (broken) pattern and it’s implied they all perished (save for Martin) and what of the complications of re-making a BP with the Jewel? It’s implied it “gets absorbed” by the Primal Pattern, but if Merle rewrote it with the Jewel (like Oberon did with the Primal Pattern) wouldn’t the remade Pattern become a sentient and “whole” Pattern on itself, like the creations of Corwin and Dworkin? If so, then why would the Primal Pattern be able to “take” Merlin’s Pattern, yet is not able to absorb Corwin’s?
What about the “broken” path? I can get behind the whole BP’s wrongly reflecting the Primal Pattern, but… you know, it’s still a PATTERN, a linear path. what IS “the break” or “Gap” in itself? Is “the Gap” actually the reflection of Martin’s blood upon the primal pattern (and did it appear much later)? If yes, why don’t we see a “Gap” or “break” in the Pattern of Amber, Rebma, or Tir (if we assume they are BPs?) For that matter, how come we don’t see the effect of Martin’s blood upon the Primal Pattern reflected in the patterns of Amber, Rebma, and Tir? Or, is the caused effect of Martin’s blood all those billions of would-be initiates who dare and die upon the Patterns? (now that’s a morbid thought)
And, if “The gap” is indeed a reflection of Martin’s spilled blood… how the hell get the BP’s remade? How come the BP’s didn’t heal simultaneously when Oberon rewrote the Primal Pattern? Does Martin have to rewrite every single broken pattern in existence with the Jewel of Judgement to heal them? Could EVERYONE, and I mean, everyone, be able to walk those healed patterns?
If every universe close by Amber has a BP…. where would the BP be located on our Shadow Earth?
So… uhh… what do you think?
Let me start by saying metaphysics described by canon characters is clearly an experienced voice giving a ‘truth’ to an inexperienced voice. It is to be considered short-hand, not an elaborate tretise. In my campaign, I’ve made assumptions that, again, develop Zelazny’s theme of slow reveals of deeper understanding. YMMV
Throughout the canon, the amberites speak of shadow as a reflection of the poles of reality. This attitude is centuries old, perhaps even thousands of years old, learned from Oberon. Even so, they treat shadow people as inferior imitations of the Courts and Amber. I submit to you, they treat them as broken. They are weaker, by a lot in some places, but having many qualities of real beings.
So much so, that amberites can ‘disguise’ themselves as these broken shadow people. it isn’t hard to pretend to have these flaws, unless the science/magic of a culture are advanced enough to detect the disguise.
IMHO, we are shown in canon that Amber, Tir, and Rebma are NOT broken patterns. There is nothing missing in them. They all have their own character and mysteries and they are whole. An entire book could be written on the premise that this is a wrong idea, a Big Lie, and that the Primal Pattern has a people who have disguised themselves from amberite notice. But the canon being a Big Lie…that’s not this discussion.
The point being that BP (broken patterns) are unique to shadow because they are founded in shadow. They are distortions, bad copies, missing essential qualities, but based on some of the same primal attributes of the universe. Further, this strongly suggests that you cannot ‘heal’ one and make it an essential pattern like Amber. It will revert quickly or its energies will be so changed that it may make the entire shadow unstable. The BP is grounded in a shadow and that shadow does not have the stuff to keep that BP essential. That BP engine may run for a while on ‘premium primal energy’ or being willed to a higher function by an amberite, for instance, but you cannot make a Model T into a race car by some small practice of juggling energy. This is NOT a case of Oberon with the jewel fixing a damaged Pattern in a place that has had one for thousands of years and CAN run in harmony with that Pattern. Recall that Dworkin thought fixing it was impossible or very tedious compared to starting over.
So in my view, a BP is not quite at all a Pattern. It could be argued it is many other things, a distortion, an echo of Pattern, perhaps even a storm of Pattern like energy, but reflection is actually a poor analogy of what BP is. BP is a slapdash storm crudely tuned to universal powers. It isn’t linear or a whole path, it is a jumble of shards that contain energy that will kill you if you touch the wrong thing. Jasra specifically describes staying AWAY from the energy bits and sliding into the center carefully as if on a journey through a storm whirling death.
Martin’s blood on the Primal? That’s a whole other case of bad stuff. Don’t conflate the two. Broken Patterns existed before Martin. YMMV
Where do Broken Patterns appear in the universe? Are they all around Amber? Are there a limited number of them? Nine? Twenty-seven? No.
So if they are not reflections, then they don’t have to be near Amber. We already know also that shadows closer to Amber have more of the whole qualities of Amber, though still not whole. These are Unlikely places for Broken Patterns to exist.
You have to get away from the Courts or Amber to places that have been stressed, like the Keep of Four Worlds, or to shadows where terrible ruin has fallen on the primal energies. Apocalyptic shadows. Twisted shadows. Even shadows where people no longer exist are likely spots for Broken Pattern to have formed. So consider that Broken Pattern, like shadow people, come in many dark flavors in infinite shadow. They have the same theme, ie, something is wrong with them, they are raggedly a patchwork of bad choices.
IMC (in my campaign), I often give attunement to BP for free or with a narrative story contribution from the PC who wants it. I also assign 5 points of Bad Stuff to the PC they cannot refuse. If this happens from ongoing story, then it immediately changes the stuff balance of that PC. If this is a character design from start, the PC can spend points to negate the BP Bad Stuff up to zero points. Meaning the free power cost their build 5 points. No character with BP is going to have Good Stuff.
So finally, as example, where would a Broken Pattern appear on our Earth (which Earth would have to be nowhere close to Amber if this was to be true), I can think of two places that seem right to me for the above speculation. Hiroshima in 1945 or the Tunguska impact event in 1908. I favor the Tunguska Event.